Electric motors are preferred over gears, ratchets, and other mechanisms for powering modern standing desks. This is because electric motors are more reliable, efficient, and cost-effective than traditional mechanical systems.
If you are considering purchasing an electric motor standing desk, you will realize that there are several types to choose from. The two most popular electric standing desks are dual-motor and single-motor desks. Both types have their own advantages and disadvantages, making it necessary to research each type before deciding which is the best option for your needs.
Initially, the debate regarding Single vs Dual Motor Standing Desks may appear to have a clear resolution. The common perception is that having two motors is always preferable., which is not always true.
By comparing both options comprehensively, we will gain a deeper understanding of the complexities involved. The following information outlines the advantages and disadvantages of both single-motor models and dual-motor systems. It also explains their differences and identifies which option may be most appropriate for you and your workspace.
What is a Single-Motor Standing Desk?
A single-motor desk is a type of standing desk powered by a single motor. It’s usually the most affordable and easiest to operate. It allows you to adjust the height of the desk with the press of a button. However, it doesn’t offer the same level of customization as other standing desks.
What is a Dual-Motor Standing Desk?
A dual-motor standing desk is a type of adjustable standing desk that is powered by two electric motors. By utilizing two motors, the dual-motor standing desk can provide a broader height adjustment range, allowing for greater flexibility in both sitting and standing positions.
Single vs Dual Motor Standing Desks – A Comprehensive Comparison
When choosing a standing desk with either one or two motors, consider factors like desk size, budget, manufacturer, style, size, the working mechanism of desks, and intended use to determine the best option. Below we’ll compare the two standing desks based on different factors:
Factor # 1: Motor Quality
The quality of the motors plays a significant role in determining the overall quality of a standing desk. A single-motor standing desk will be suitable for most needs if the motor is manufactured with precision and high-quality materials backed by a reputable manufacturer.
On the other hand, if low-cost suppliers produce the motors with minimal quality control, even a dual-motor standing desk will not perform as well as a single-motor standing desk manufactured to a higher standard.
However, obtaining information regarding the quality of the motors while shopping for a standing desk can be challenging. Many desk vendors do not reveal the source of their components.
One possible indicator of the quality of the motors can be deduced from the warranty offered by the company. A comprehensive and long-term warranty suggests that the company is confident in its products and willing to provide support for any faulty parts, including the motor module. On the other hand, a limited warranty may indicate that the company is aware of potential issues with the motors and does not wish to take responsibility for addressing them.
Factor # 2: Weight Capacity
It is a common misconception that a higher number of motors equals a better weight capacity. However, this is only sometimes the case, as a single, powerful motor can outperform two weak motors. It is important to note that the motors must work together effectively to support the total weight of the desk, especially in the event of an unbalanced weight distribution.
Standing desks with a single motor typically have a weight capacity of approximately 250 lbs. While dual-motor designs may have a higher weight capacity, it is not double that of a single-motor desk. Opting for a dual-motor design is recommended if you anticipate working near the weight capacity. However, reaching the weight capacity during regular operation is unlikely for most office and home needs.
It is also recommended to consider whether the desk has overload protection. Exceeding the stated weight capacity can result in motor damage, reduced lifespan, slowed performance, or complete failure. However, this will not be a concern if you do not intend to reach the weight capacity.
Factor # 3: Motor Reliability
Reliable motors are crucial for the smooth operation of standing desks. Quality materials, manufacturing, and oversight influence motor reliability. Most standing desks function well right after assembly; if there’s a malfunction, warranties usually cover replacements within the first few weeks. However, daily transitions between sitting and standing over time can strain the motor.
Factors such as over-greased motors, poor-quality magnets, degraded coils, worn plastic gears, and exposed wires can cause slipping, wear and tear, and positional slipping. To ensure reliability, select motors made of high-quality parts, assembled with care, and protected from the environment.
The notion of two motors being better than one for reliability is not always accurate. Smaller motors used in desks with two motors may not be as powerful or reliable. Additionally, both motors need to work in sync for the system to function correctly, making it a potential double failure point.
It is important to note that the reliability of a motor system greatly depends on the manufacturer. While a single motor may appear less reliable compared to a dual motor system, a single motor can exhibit superior reliability if made with excellent quality materials.
Factor # 4: Accessibility and Repairing Right
As the warranty period of a standing desk ends, the owner is faced with the possibility of encountering issues with its motor. While lifetime warranties are scarce among standing desk manufacturers, the eventuality of the desk being out of warranty necessitates consideration of potential repair options. These options include purchasing a new desk, acquiring a replacement motor, or repairing the motor itself.
The ability to repair an electronic device, such as the motor of a standing desk, may be hindered by the right to repair laws in different regions. This poses challenges in accessing and fixing the device.
It is worth noting that single-motor standing desks are typically more accessible for repair or replacement compared to dual-motor desks. The former often has a central column with an easily accessible motor, whereas the latter often has motors embedded in housings within the legs. This, however, may vary depending on the company and design.
In case of a malfunction in a single-motor standing desk, it can still be used as a stationary desk as long as the break does not occur amid the transition. Conversely, a failure in a dual-motor desk typically results in the desk becoming tilted and unusable until the motor is replaced or the desk is completely lowered.
The continuous advancement of technology offers a compelling reason for replacement rather than repair. Within the three to five-year lifespan of a standing desk, there may be significant improvements in motors, cost-effectiveness, and control mechanisms.
Factor # 5: Desk Design
The design of standing desks can vary depending on the type of motor used. Typically, single-motor standing desks feature the motor in a visible location. Conversely, dual-motor desks often have a more streamlined appearance due to the smaller size of the motors, which are tucked away.
This difference in design allows for a range of aesthetics depending on the user’s needs and preferences. A dual-motor standing desk may be a more suitable option for individuals who place a high value on aesthetics.
Factor # 6: Adjustment Speed
Adjustment speed is another key aspect that differentiates the performance levels of single-motor desks from dual-motor desks. This factor becomes more important in shared workspaces where many people have to use the same desk during different parts of the day.
In this regard, the adjustment speed of dual motor desks is much better than single motor desks as they use two motors for their work. However, single motor desks with dual speed are also available in the market but the price of such desks would be much higher.
Factor # 7: Aesthetics
In contrast, dual motor desks are much more expensive as they have additional and faster features. So if you are new to using a standing desk, it is better to buy a single motor desk so that you get to know its workability and effectiveness. However, if you already work on a standing desk and you are considering upgrading it, you can go for a dual motor desk.
An aesthetically pleasing working space puts a huge impact on the mental health and productivity level of users. As far as aesthetics are concerned, dual motor desks have a sleek and clean-looking appearance as compared to single motor desks. In dual motor desks, motors are separately attached to each leg right under the desk, staying unnoticed and hidden from sight.
In single-motor desks, a motor is attached between the legs which makes it visible. However, the aesthetics of the desk also vary from individual to individual. Some people might find a single-motor desk more pleasing and visually charming.
Factor # 8: Durability
In terms of durability, dual-motor desks tend to last longer than single-motor desks. The weight is equally distributed between two motors, therefore, there is no pressure on a single motor. In a single-motor desk, all the pressure is exerted on a single motor therefore it is more likely to expire earlier.
As single desks have lower weight capacity, therefore, the motor has to struggle more to lift all the weight. This makes the desk more susceptible to damage and breaks if the user reaches the maximum capacity. A dual motor desk doesn’t have to work a lot as it has a higher load capacity. Therefore, there are fewer chances of damage and break if the motor reaches maximum weight capacity in dual motor desks.
Factor # 9: Cost
In addition to appearance, the cost of a standing desk is frequently the most significant factor in the purchasing decision. Dual motors typically make the standing desk more expensive than a single-motor system due to the complexity of the additional moving parts and technology involved. Similarly, larger standing desks are often associated with a higher price point.
Final Thoughts – What Kind of Standing Desk is Best?
In conclusion, the choice ultimately rests with you. The distinction between a single or dual motor sit-stand desk largely depends on quality rather than quantity.
Generally speaking, high-quality dual-motor models will offer superior performance compared to single-motor alternatives, albeit at a higher cost. The most suitable motor setup for you will depend on your desired speed of adjustment and load capacity needs, as well as your budget, which is the ultimate determining factor.